Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates has been summoned to give an account of some controversial remarks on India, made on a podcast by LinkedIn’s founder Reid Hoffman. Gates characterized India as “a laboratory” to try things out, prompting old criticisms made about the type of projects in which the foundation has been implicated in India.
Apart from the controversy, Gates commended India’s progress in the country’s health, education, and socioeconomic areas. He indicated that India’s progress offers a path in the international sense. However, as per his detractors, it is from these pronouncements that India has turned out to be a volunteer base for experimental programs.
He said:
“India is an example of a country where there’s plenty of things that are difficult there—the health, nutrition, education is improving, and they are stable enough and generating their government revenue enough that it’s very likely that 20 years from now people will be dramatically better off. It’s kind of a laboratory to try things that then when you prove them out in India, you can take to other places.”
“It’s a kind of laboratory to try things. When proven in India, they can then be taken to other places.”
The backlash has highlighted a 2009 clinical trial supported by the Gates Foundation that reportedly abused poor tribal populations. A Dark Past Resurfaces In 2009, a trial co-organized by PATH, an NGO supported by the Gates Foundation, screened a cervical cancer vaccine in 14,000 tribal schoolgirls in Telangana and Gujarat.
While the deaths of seven of the participants were reported later to be due to unrelated causes, the significant adverse effects and ethical wrongs provided a dark pallor to this study. Reportedly, hostel wardens signed consent forms, instead of parents, which made families unaware of possible risks.
Critiques of Gates and his entourage are also that, they have been using communities that have no access to health care. All are viewing these trials as plunder of the masses of Punjab but in the name of charity.
Bill Gates’ Controversial Remarks on India: A Legacy of Ethical Concerns
The dispute is in question regarding the nature and effect of foreign-aided projects in India. A Scotland-based doctor, “The Skin Doctor” X, challenged the ethics behind such trials and accused Gates of exploiting India as a laboratory for global ambitions. How many Gates-funded NGOs are [attempting the same experiments] in India and Africa? He wondered, pointing to a necessity for more attention to the contribution of foreign actors in informing Indian policy.
Gates Foundation has repeatedly denied any wrongdoings and claimed that it’s continuing to serve global health. However, the process still needs review, and discussions about the scope of overseas development aid pose questions.
Also, see: Man criticizes Mahinda car designs, Anand Mahindra replies